Evidence Record

Modularity in Biological Systems

Modularity  •  Patterns of Design in Living Systems
A Visit With Jesus

Biological systems are often organized into interacting subsystems whose components work together more closely with one another than with the system as a whole.

The Investigative Question

Why are biological systems frequently organized into modules?

What We Observe

Genes, proteins, signaling pathways, metabolic pathways, anatomical structures, and developmental processes can form recognizable functional groupings.

Scientific Background

Modularity can reduce unwanted interactions, allow components to be reused in different contexts, and permit parts of a system to change without disrupting every other part.

Why It Matters

Modular organization can contribute to robustness, adaptability, and the evolution of complex systems.

What Is Known

Network analysis and experimental biology have identified modular organization in many cellular and developmental systems, although module boundaries are not always sharp.

What Is Proposed

Evolutionary models investigate how modularity can arise through duplication, selection, changes in network connectivity, and historical constraints.

What Remains Uncertain

Biological systems are highly interconnected, so describing a system as modular can depend upon the scale and criteria used to define the modules.

Design Relevance

Modularity resembles an important principle of human engineering. Its design relevance depends upon whether the biological pattern contains features that distinguish purposeful modular construction from modularity produced through evolutionary processes.

Assessment

Modularity is a useful and measurable feature of many biological systems, but its existence alone does not determine how those systems originated.

Research Sources

Hartwell et al. — From Molecular to Modular Cell Biology
Leland H. Hartwell; John J. Hopfield; Stanislas Leibler; Andrew W. Murray • Nature • 1999
Use: Biological Modularity
Relevance: Provides a foundational treatment of cellular organization in terms of functional modules composed of interacting molecular components.
DOI: 10.1038/35011540
Alon — Network Motifs
Uri Alon • Nature Reviews Genetics • 2007
Use: Network Motifs
Relevance: Examines recurring regulatory network motifs that function as identifiable building blocks within biological networks.
DOI: 10.1038/nrg2102
Hintze and Adami — Evolution of Complex Modular Biological Networks
Arend Hintze; Christoph Adami • PLOS Computational Biology • 2008
Use: Evolution Of Modularity
Relevance: Provides a computational evolutionary model in which modular organization emerges in artificial biological networks under specified environmental conditions.
DOI: 10.1371/journal.pcbi.0040023